Whose Gun Rights? Black Woman Incarcerated for Self-Defense

Racism rules when it comes to guns and self-defense – why we need black lives matter.

Last month Detroit-based environmental justice activist Siwatu-Salama Ra was sentenced to two years in prison for brandishing an unloaded gun in an effort to protect her two year-old daughter and mother from an aggressor. Ra’s “felonious assault” conviction is a blatant contradiction of Michigan’s stand-your-ground laws – yet we haven’t heard anything from NRA supporters, proving once more that the gun rights movement is only concerned with protecting the “freedom” of white men. 

Michigan is an open carry state, with stand-your-ground laws which legally justify a defendant’s decision to use force instead of retreating from an attack. Other cases which have explored the stand-your-ground defense include George Zimmerman, who claimed to fear for his life when he shot and killed 17-year-old Trayvon Martin.

However, stand-your-ground laws are notoriously arbitrary and racist in their application. We saw this in Florida back in 2012 when Marissa Alexander was sentenced to 20 years in prison for shooting at a wall to to scare off her abusive husband. She tried to use Florida’s stand-your-ground law to prove her use of a weapon was in self-defense and though her husband even admitted to abusing her, the courts ruled against her.

In the wake of Alexander’s trial, the Urban Institute reported that in stand-your-ground states, 34% of homicides are considered justified by the law when white shooters kill black people, yet when black shooters kill white people, only 3% of cases are considered justifiable. Neither Alexander nor Ra shot or harmed anyone, yet as Black women they were denied the protection of the stand-your-ground law which is afforded to so many men.

Ra’s case is also a prime example of the questionable investigative policies of the Detroit Police Department. After Ra revealed her gun, Ra’s neighbor took photos as evidence and immediately filed a report to the police department and because the neighbor reported first, Detroit Police considered Ra the assailant and. Michigan’s stand-your-ground law only applies for self-defense, precluding Ra from using it. What’s worse, the state’s mandatory sentencing laws for crimes involving guns blocked the judge from using discretion on the case, which the jury was unaware of before  arriving to their verdict – all of which ended with Ra, pregnant, being sentenced to two years in prison without firing a shot.

Victoria Burton-Harris, one of Ra’s attorneys, summarizes the relationship between racism and criminal justice:

“You’re allowed to behave differently when you’re fearful based on the color of your skin. George Zimmerman was allowed to be fearful and to act on that fear… Juxtapose that next to my client who had a car coming at her mother, and that same car had just presented danger to her child. It was driven by the complaining witness, but Siwatu wasn’t allowed to be fearful and rely on her government-licensed and sanctioned firearm to ward off her attacker.”

To add to the situation, Siwatu-Salama Ra is expecting to give birth in July. Patrisse Khan-Cullors reported on Democracy Now that since being taken to prison, Ra has been shackled during doctor visits and will likely be shackled when giving birth. Restraining pregnant people is inhumane and harms both the woman and baby’s health. On top of this Ra, as a practicing Muslim woman, has been denied pork-free meals and a hijab for her five daily prayers. Without proper protein, she’s lost weight, potentially complicating her pregnancy.

Siwatu-Salama Ra is not the first Black woman unfairly targeted and abused by our criminal justice system. As students across the country demand gun reform, we must ensure that the experiences and needs of women and people of color, who suffer disproportionately from gun violence and criminalization, are centralized within the movement. Let’s call out the gun lobby’s movement for “freedom” as the racist farce that it is. Sign up for updates on Ra’s website, send her letters, and consider donating funds for her appeal.

Image Header Credit: Blavity