Monthly Archives: October 2015
Arizona struggles to find a credible court witness to defend “abortion reversal” law
Remember that law Arizona passed this year requiring abortion providers to inform lie to their patients that it’s possible to “reverse” a medication abortion? Now, the state’s attempt to defend the law against a court challenge is floundering because it’s having trouble finding anyone to defend the law who qualifies as an expert witness.
Attorneys for the State of Arizona asked the court to postpone the trial, in part because its primary expert to defend the law lacked the “publication and research background and experience” to be qualified as an expert witness.
Federal courts are required to determine whether an expert is qualified to testify, including whether the expert’s methodology is sufficiently reliable to support the proposed opinions. The court must further decide whether the expert’s proposed testimony will, through the application of scientific, technical, or specialized expertise, assist the court in understanding the evidence or determining a fact at issue.
Dr. Mary Davenport of El Sobrante, California, is the State of Arizona’s principal witness in support of the measure. A member of the American Association of Pro-Life Obstetricians & Gynecologists, Davenport bases her claims that a medically induced abortion can be reversed on a single anecdotal study of six patients, four of whom Davenport claims were able to carry pregnancies to term, despite ingesting mifepristone, by taking a dose of progesterone shortly after ingesting mifepristone.
No other scientific data exists to support Davenport’s claim.
While a study of six patients apparently doesn’t meet the court’s standard of evidence based on “reliable methods” that have “widespread acceptance,” it was plenty for the Arizona state lawmakers who passed the law.
As Robin Marty wrote at the time, this law puts the anti-choice movement’s hypocrisy on full display. Most anti-choice restrictions — telemedicine bans, admitting privilege requirements, etc. — are justified under the very flimsy guise of protecting patient safety. “Meanwhile, these same people are suggesting that patients Google a website, call a hotline, be hooked up with a doctor they have never seen and rush straight to a place to be injected with massive amounts of hormones without any FDA approval of that procedure, long-term studies of the effects, or even much of a testing pool of subjects to draw data from.”
US state of Ohio delays all executions until 2017
The Midwestern state has put off all scheduled executions until 2017 because of difficulty obtaining approved drugs to carry out lethal injections. The shortage has been caused by an embargo by European pharma companies.
Washington Post “Inadvertently” Publishes Article Declaring Joe Biden Candidacy
“Vice President Biden plans to enter the contest for the 2016 presidential nomination,” the article read before it was pulled.
Playground in Tenement Alley, Boston, MA, 1909
09_7R2_DSC2835 copy
‘And Then The Race Riots Start’: A Look Back At Glenn Beck’s Ebola Predictions … – Right Wing Watch
Right Wing Watch |
‘And Then The Race Riots Start’: A Look Back At Glenn Beck’s Ebola Predictions …
Right Wing Watch Beck’s nightmare scenario never came close to materializing and after the Ebola panic waned, Beck simply moved on and conveniently forgot all of dire false warnings that he had issued in the midst of the crisis. But we have not forgotten. In fact, we … |
Justin Trudeau elected as Canada’s next prime minister
Canadian voters elect Liberal Party leader Justin Trudeau as prime minister, dramatically ending the nine-year government of Stephen Harper.
S.Koreans travel to N.Korea to reunite with war-divided kin
SEOUL, South Korea (AP) — Hundreds of South Koreans headed to North Korea on Tuesday for temporary reunions with family members most haven’t had word of since the turmoil of the Korean War more than 60 years ago….
Julia Gillard lends support to Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign – video
The former Australian prime minister appears in a video for Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign. Guardian Australia understands the Clinton camp approached Julia Gillard to be in the video, which was shot in New York this month. Making several appearances, she praises the former secretary of state’s commitment to girls’ education and diplomacy in the Asia-Pacific region
You must be logged in to post a comment.